Car Dealership Websites Are One of the Most-Sued Industries Online. Here's What to Fix First.

If you run a car dealership, you have probably never thought of your website as a legal liability. It is a lead machine: inventory, financing applications, trade-in tools, service scheduling. But over the past few years, dealership websites have quietly become one of the most frequently targeted business types in website accessibility lawsuits and demand letters in the United States. Plaintiffs’ firms file these claims in waves, sometimes hitting dozens of dealers in a single month, and the dealership almost always ends up paying to settle and remediate.

The frustrating part is that most dealers did not build the thing being sued. You licensed a website from one of a handful of automotive-specific platform vendors, the same vendors thousands of other dealers use. When one of those templates has an accessibility defect, every dealer running it inherits the same problem and the same exposure. And courts have generally not accepted “my vendor built it” as a defense. The dealership is the public accommodation. The dealership is responsible for whether its customers can use the site.

This article explains, in plain language, why dealer sites attract so much litigation and what to fix first. You do not need to be a developer to follow it.

Why dealerships specifically?

Three things make automotive retail a magnet for these claims.

First, dealer sites are huge and feature-dense. A typical dealership website has hundreds of vehicle listings, each with photo galleries; a searchable inventory with filters for make, model, price, and mileage; credit applications; payment calculators; trade-in valuation widgets; service scheduling; and live chat. Every one of those features is a common accessibility failure point. The more interactive controls a site has, the more opportunities there are for something to break for a keyboard or screen reader user.

Second, the industry runs on shared templates. Because so many dealers use the same few platforms, a plaintiff’s firm can test one site, find a barrier, and then reasonably assume the same defect exists across every dealer on that platform. That turns one finding into a mailing list. It is efficient for the filers and expensive for the dealers.

Third, the transactions are high value and the forms are everywhere. Dealership sites push visitors toward conversion at every turn: financing applications, lead forms, “value my trade” pop-ups, “get e-price” buttons. When those forms are inaccessible, a disabled customer is blocked at the exact moment they were ready to act, which is precisely the kind of concrete barrier these lawsuits are built around.

What the law actually requires

The core claim is brought under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act, which treats your dealership as a public accommodation. Federal courts have repeatedly allowed website accessibility cases against dealers to move forward. Title III does not impose federal monetary fines, but it does allow injunctive relief (a court order to fix the site) and, critically, the plaintiff’s attorney’s fees. That fee provision is what makes these cases economical to file in bulk.

State laws add real money on top. In California, the Unruh Civil Rights Act provides minimum statutory damages of $4,000 per violation, and serial filers there are well known. New York’s state and city human rights laws allow compensatory damages and attorney’s fees. So a single inaccessible site can generate exposure under federal and state law at the same time.

There is no official “ADA certification” for websites, and no government agency pre-approves your site. The practical standard courts and settlements point to is the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, currently WCAG 2.2, at Level AA. You do not need to memorize the guidelines. You need to make sure the handful of things below actually work.

Fix #1: Make your inventory search usable without a mouse

The heart of your site is the inventory search, and the filters that go with it are one of the most common things that break. Try this yourself: load your inventory page, put your mouse aside, and use only the Tab key and Enter to narrow the results by price, make, or mileage.

On a lot of dealer sites, you simply cannot. The price and mileage sliders are mouse-only with no way to type a number. The dropdowns are custom-built widgets that the keyboard cannot reach or open. And when you do manage to apply a filter, nothing announces that the results changed, so a blind shopper using a screen reader has no idea the list updated.

The fix is to make every filter a proper, labeled control that works with a keyboard, to offer a number you can type next to any slider, and to announce the new result count when the list changes. This is work for whoever maintains your platform, but it is well-understood work, and it is the single highest-value area to address because the inventory search is where shopping starts.

Fix #2: Make financing and lead forms completable

Your credit application and your lead forms are where the money is, and they are also where inaccessible error handling does the most damage. The common problems are easy to spot once you know what to look for:

  • Fields with no visible label, or a label that disappears once you start typing.
  • Required fields marked only with a red asterisk, which a screen reader may not announce.
  • Error messages shown only as red text, with no explanation of which field is wrong or how to fix it.
  • Long applications that, on submission, dump you back to the top with no clear path to the problem.

For a disabled applicant, an inaccessible error experience is a dead end. They cannot tell what went wrong, so they cannot finish, so you lose a financing lead. The fix is to label every field clearly, mark required fields in a way assistive technology can announce, and present errors as plain text tied to the specific field, with the cursor moved to the first problem on submit. Test it by filling out your own application with a screen reader turned on and deliberately leaving a field blank to see what happens.

Fix #3: Give your vehicle photos and videos text alternatives

Dealership listings are image-heavy by design. The problem is that the information those images carry, the condition and features of the car, is invisible to someone who cannot see them. Two things go wrong constantly.

The galleries themselves are often mouse-only carousels with thumbnail controls a keyboard cannot reach. And the images frequently have no alt text, or have alt text that is just a filename like “IMG_4471.jpg,” which tells a screen reader user nothing. The same applies to 360-degree spin viewers and video walkarounds, which often have no keyboard controls, no captions, and no text summary.

You do not need to write a paragraph for every photo. You need meaningful descriptions of what matters (exterior color, visible condition, key features) and galleries that can be operated with a keyboard. For video walkarounds, add captions and a short text summary so the information is available to everyone, not just people who can watch and hear.

Fix #4: Check your pop-ups, calculators, and trade-in widgets

Dealer sites are full of third-party widgets: trade-in appraisal tools, payment calculators, and aggressive lead-capture pop-ups. These are loaded from outside vendors and often arrive with their own accessibility defects baked in.

The one that causes the most complaints is the pop-up that cannot be closed with a keyboard. A keyboard user tabs into it, gets stuck, and cannot get back to the page, which effectively ends their visit. Test every interstitial and modal on your site: it should open with focus moved into it, it should close with the Escape key, and closing it should return you to where you were. Calculators and trade-in tools should have labeled fields you can type into and should announce their results, not just flash a number on screen.

If a third-party widget cannot be made accessible, give people an alternative: a clearly stated phone number or an accessible contact form that accomplishes the same thing.

What about an accessibility overlay?

You have probably been pitched an overlay widget, the one-line script that promises instant ADA compliance. Be skeptical. Overlays have not reliably stopped demand letters, and in some cases dealerships running an overlay have been sued anyway, with the overlay itself cited as a barrier. There is no shortcut script that substitutes for the four fixes above. Spend the money on making the actual site work.

A realistic first step

You do not have to remediate everything this week. Start with a 20-minute self-check: put the mouse down and try to filter your inventory, fill out your credit application, page through a vehicle gallery, and close every pop-up using only the keyboard. Wherever you get stuck, a disabled customer gets stuck too, and that is exactly what a tester for a plaintiff’s firm is looking for. Fix those points first, document what you have done, and put a real accessibility statement on the site with a way to report problems.

The dealers who get blindsided are the ones who assumed the vendor handled it. The ones who come out fine are the ones who checked.

We’re building a simple accessibility checker for non-developers — no DevTools, no jargon. Join our waitlist to get early access.